Melville Attica Many of these are smaller cities in New York that have a high percentage of its residents with an account on Ashley Madison. Apalachin, NY 1. Go directly to the source of people actively trying to cheat — Ashley Madison users. We then matched each zip code to its wifes in Potsdam Cheating city. Which means, in theory, they have a high number of people looking to discreetly hook up with a woman. Percentage of city potentially cheating: Almost 1 wifes in Potsdam Cheating 5 of the population had an address registered on Ashley Madison.